Indonesia passes asset forfeiture law amid civil society concerns

Jakarta – Indonesia’s newly passed asset forfeiture law has drawn criticism over its limited scope, lack of meaningful public participation and the concentration of authority in institutions controlled by the president, raising questions about whether it will be effective in tackling illicit wealth linked to extractive industries.

Firdaus Cahyadi, founder of Indonesia Climate Justice Literacy (ICJL), on Friday, November 20, said the legislation was passed suddenly, without meaningful public involvement, potentially allowing political and business elites to exert disproportionate influence over its provisions.

One major concern, he said, is that environmental crimes, including those committed in the forestry, plantation and mining sectors, are not explicitly recognised as standalone predicate offences under the new law.

“The problem is that most political elites have extractive businesses, creating the potential for crimes committed by the extractive industries to escape the scope of this law,” Firdaus said.

He pointed to provisions restricting the categories of offences covered by the legislation, which include corruption and six other categories: narcotics and psychotropic substances, terrorism and terrorism financing, human smuggling, arms and dangerous materials smuggling, human trafficking, and certain forms of technology-enabled fraud or embezzlement.

The exclusion of environmental, forestry, plantation and mining offences as independent predicate crimes could limit the law’s ability to target assets accumulated through environmental destruction and natural resource exploitation, he argued.

Firdaus also questioned the governance structure established under the law, particularly provisions placing the newly created Asset Management Agency and Supervisory Agency under the authority of the president.

He said this arrangement would further centralise power in the presidency, following the establishment of the National Agrarian Reform Agency (BRAN) under the recently enacted Agrarian Reform Management Law (UU PRA).

“The problem is that the president and people within his circle also have extractive businesses, potentially allowing them to escape law enforcement under both the Asset Forfeiture Law and the Agrarian Reform Management Law,” he said.

Parliament passes long-awaited legislation

The House of Representatives (DPR) passed the Law on Asset Forfeiture Related to Corruption and Other Criminal Offences during a plenary session at the parliamentary complex in Senayan, Jakarta, on Thursday, November 19.

The legislation was passed after an 18-year process, marking a long-awaited step towards strengthening the government’s ability to recover assets derived from criminal activities.

Under Article 3, asset forfeiture can be carried out either following a final and legally binding criminal court ruling or without a criminal conviction against the perpetrator.

However, non-conviction-based asset forfeiture is subject to specific conditions. Article 6 allows authorities to pursue forfeiture when a suspect or defendant has died, fled, is permanently ill, cannot be identified, or cannot be located.

The provision also establishes a minimum asset value of Rp1 billion (USD 54,738) for forfeiture without a criminal conviction.

Importantly, asset forfeiture without a criminal conviction does not eliminate the perpetrator’s criminal liability, meaning criminal proceedings can still be pursued where applicable.

Two new agencies under presidential authority

The legislation establishes two new institutions to oversee the management and supervision of forfeited assets.

Under Article 53, asset management will be carried out by an agency established by the president. Article 61 similarly provides for a supervisory agency, also established by the president, to oversee asset forfeiture and management.

These provisions have become a point of concern for Firdaus, who argues that placing both institutions under presidential authority could weaken independent oversight and create potential conflicts of interest.

The legislation also stipulates that it will not apply retroactively. Under Article 72, asset forfeiture and management under the law can only be applied to criminal offences committed after the legislation comes into force.

Article 74 provides that the law will become operational 12 months after its promulgation and after the two agencies have been established.

While the passage of the legislation establishes a new legal framework for recovering criminal assets, concerns raised by civil society over its coverage and institutional independence point to challenges that could shape its implementation. (nsh)

Banner photo: Indonesian Parliament Building. Rohani Budi Prihatin/shutterstock.com

Like this article? share it

More Post

Receive the latest news

Subscribe To Our Weekly Newsletter

Get notified about new articles